Chile's Supreme Court finds the blocking bill unnecessary

Chile's Supreme Court

Chile's Supreme Court told the Senate that the bill to strengthen judicial blocking of online betting sites is not needed. The 3 articles the initiative would add to the Civil Procedure Code, 238 bis, 238 ter and 238 quater, look unnecessary and redundant against the enforcement rules already in Title XIX of Book I of that same code.

The court does not dispute that the problem exists, it disputes that the tool works. Its report states there is a mismatch between what the bill wants to solve, the deliberate use of technological mechanisms by the platforms to keep operating in defiance of a judicially ordered block, and the formula chosen to achieve it.

The distinction matters because it reassigns where the failure sits. If the courts already hold powers to enforce their rulings, then what fails is not procedural law but the physical execution of the block, which depends on telecommunications operators rather than judges.

The court itself says so in those terms. It warned that the difficulties in enforcing the orders could answer to factors other than any insufficiency of judicial powers or of the discussion opportunities built into the procedures.

The second objection is about legal architecture. The court considered that placing specific provisions on blocking digital platforms inside a general body of judicial procedure could create systemic coherence problems, and suggested instead examining changes to sector telecommunications regulation or to the law governing games of chance.

That suggestion moves the file to a different committee and a different logic. A reform of the Civil Procedure Code is debated as a justice matter; a reform of the telecommunications law is debated with the Telecommunications Undersecretariat at the table, the body that physically carries out the blocks.

The figures accumulated over the past year explain why Congress sought a procedural way out. Since 19 August the Gambling Casinos Superintendency has ordered 174 illegal sites blocked, and the Telecommunications Undersecretariat has accumulated 6 administrative and 3 judicial challenges over those closures, plus a lawsuit from Latamwin, that is 10 open fronts on the same mechanism.

Seen that way, the court's diagnosis has empirical backing. The bottleneck does not appear at the judicial stage but afterwards, when the order leaves the court and enters an administrative and technical circuit where platforms can change domain faster than the system blocks them.

The report's passage had a speed of its own. The Supreme Court's full bench examined the opinion on 9 November and sent it to the Senate presidency on the 12th, 3 days later.

The challenged initiative came in as a parliamentary motion and proposes regulating the enforcement of judicial rulings ordering the blocking of websites and online gambling platforms. Its declared aim is to stop platforms operating through new domains or alternative sites despite holding a blocking order.

The opinion arrives with the Senate debating 2 opposite paths at once. The Economic Affairs Committee advanced parliamentary amendments aimed at banning the platforms, and in parallel the text the executive sent to set up a licensing regime remains alive.

The 3 pieces point at different places in the same problem. Banning defines what is illegal, licensing defines who may operate legally, and the motion the court has just objected to defines how a decision already taken is enforced, which is the link where Chile's system has been showing its limits.

Supreme Court reports on bills are not binding, so the Senate can press on with the text as it stands, but the opinion is added to the file and tends to weigh in the floor debate, above all when the objection is not to the aim pursued but to how fit the chosen instrument is.

Tags: Chile, Supreme Court, blocking, Senate